Reformer and machines
Reformer or mat pilates: the differences and how to choose
One method, two very different ways to experience it. Here’s what really changes between reformer and mat pilates, and how to decide based on your schedule, budget and starting point.
On this page · 12 sections
- What is mat pilates and what changes with the reformer?
- Reformer vs mat pilates at a glance
- Three questions before you decide
- Your first time: what each one feels like
- Sound familiar? Who each format tends to suit
- Three very Madrid scenarios
- Is reformer strength training?
- Reformer and weight: the method’s approach
- Combining both: a few options
- Questions to ask the studio before choosing
- Your next step: read, prepare and compare
- Frequently asked questions
If you’ve ever looked at a Madrid pilates studio’s timetable, you’ll have seen classes split into two big families: machine or mat. That’s the first decision for beginners, even before choosing a studio. In this guide, “mat pilates” always means pilates on a mat, what Spanish studios may list as suelo or mat (nothing to do with the pelvic floor, suelo pélvico).
Both options are equally valid, and each feels different: resistance, group size, what you need to learn and how it fits your week all change. Let’s take it step by step.
What is mat pilates and what changes with the reformer?
Both come from the same method, developed by Joseph Pilates and named “Contrology”: movement control, core work, coordinated breathing and close attention to precision.
Mat pilates is done on a mat. The resistance is your own body: the weight of your legs and torso, and gravity. Some studios add small props (rings, resistance bands, balls), but the essence is simple: you against yourself.
The reformer is a machine: a frame with a carriage that slides along rails, attached to interchangeable springs that give more or less resistance. It also has a footbar and straps for hands or feet. For a part-by-part breakdown, see what reformer pilates is and how the machine works. Here we stick to what matters for deciding.
Reformer vs mat pilates at a glance
| Aspecto | Reformer | Mat pilates |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Machine class: moving carriage, springs, footbar and straps | Class on a mat, with or without small props |
| Resistance | Interchangeable springs: can assist or load the movement | Body weight and gravity; sometimes bands or rings |
| Equipment | Provided by the studio; no machine, no practice | A mat; easy to repeat at home |
| Instructor guidance | The instructor adjusts springs and positions; the machine gives physical feedback | Everything depends on verbal cues and your own body awareness |
| Group size | Limited by the number of machines in the room; varies by studio | Depends on the room; can be larger. Varies by studio |
| Learning curve | You learn the machine: getting on and off, changing springs, using straps | Fewer mechanics, but demanding control with no external help |
| Often suits | People wanting physical guidance and small groups, willing to pay more | People wanting a lower cost, flexibility or home practice |
| Where | Studios equipped with machines | Studios, gyms, sports centres, multi-purpose rooms, home |
| Studio rules | Many machine studios require grip socks; check first | Usually barefoot or in socks; check first |
| Relative cost | Usually more expensive per session | Usually cheaper per session |
For actual prices, payment formats and how to work out your cost per session, see how much pilates costs in Madrid. Here we focus on method, as figures change with the studio and type of class pack (bono).
Three questions before you decide
Before comparing studios, think about three things. Once they’re clear, the format almost chooses itself.
1. Budget: how much can you comfortably spend each month?
Pilates is about consistency, not heroics. If reformer means going less often than you’d like because your budget won’t stretch, starting on the mat and trying the machine now and then may work better. If money isn’t the issue, the reformer opens up other options.
2. Feedback: do you need something external to tell you?
Some people notice straight away when their pelvis shifts or they’re straining their neck; others don’t notice at all. The machine gives physical feedback: the carriage moves if you push badly and the springs push back. On the mat, that information comes from your own awareness and the instructor’s voice. If you find it hard to feel your body, reformer and a small group usually help.
3. Schedule: what does your real week look like?
Not the week you’d like, the one you have. When do you finish work? How many days can you commit to? Do you travel? Studio reformer usually means booking a spot and respecting cancellation deadlines. Mat can be done in more places and, if needed, in your living room.
Your first time: what each one feels like
On the reformer, the first surprise is that the floor moves. The carriage slides and, until you get used to it, every exercise has a wobbly moment. You learn to get on and off carefully, position yourself on the carriage and slip your feet or hands into the straps without losing your posture. It’s normal to leave your first class feeling you paid more attention to the machine than the exercise. Don’t worry: that passes.
On the mat, the surprise is usually the opposite: nothing helps you. Moves that looked easy on video demand unexpected control, and the instructor keeps returning to details (breathing, pelvis position, relaxed shoulders) that seem minor at first. Many people find the hard part isn’t doing the exercise, but doing it well and slowly.
Either way, soreness and perceived effort vary a lot from person to person, so don’t use them to judge whether the class “worked”. For tips on day one, see your first pilates class.
Sound familiar? Who each format tends to suit
These aren’t prescriptions, just common patterns. You may be the exception.
Reformer tends to suit you if:
- you prefer small groups and frequent adjustments from the instructor;
- you’re motivated by clear resistance, something to push against;
- you struggle to stay focused on slow exercises without external input;
- you can afford a higher cost per session and book ahead.
Mat pilates tends to suit you if:
- you want to start on a modest budget;
- you’d like to practise at home or while travelling;
- you want to understand the method “from the inside”, without relying on equipment;
- your schedule is irregular and you need more choice of places and times.
Three very Madrid scenarios
You leave the office at 7.30 pm
Your problem isn’t the format, it’s the clock. Before choosing machine or mat, check the time of the last class at studios on your route and how far ahead you can cancel without losing the session. Reformer spots depend on the number of machines, so after-work slots can fill up sooner.
Think about the journey too. A studio by your home means getting back, changing and heading out again. One near the office or your usual Metro or Cercanías interchange uses a trip you already make. If you work on the Castellana and live in the south, a studio halfway may suit you better than one downstairs. And if most weeks you won’t make it, weekend reformer plus mat at home on weekdays is a sensible option.
You’re a runner looking to complement your training
You’re used to moving fast and measuring effort in kilometres and pace. Your first mat class may feel slow, and holding certain positions may be harder than expected. Reformer may feel more intuitive because you feel the load, though the method is still about control, not speed.
Either fits well with your running plan: control and breathing work is a good counterbalance to the miles. If you have any niggles, tell the instructor on day one.
You’ve never exercised regularly
You can start with either. What will help most isn’t the machine or the mat but a good onboarding process. Look for studios offering an intro class, private sessions before joining a group, or clearly separate beginners’ groups.
At first, small groups and beginner-level classes give you more individual attention than a packed “all levels” class. And enjoy your own pace: the person on the next machine may have years of practice.
Is reformer strength training?
It’s one of the most common questions in studios, and the answer lies in how the machine works.
On the reformer you push or pull the carriage against springs, and that resistance can go up or down. That’s working against a load. On the mat, the load is your own body weight.
How close it gets to gym-style strength training, with measured progressive loads, depends on the class design: the springs used, the pace and how the load progresses over time. Some reformer classes focus on mobility and control; others are more demanding.
Ask at the front desk: if strength is your main goal, the studio can explain how they approach progression.
Reformer and weight: the method’s approach
Neither reformer nor mat is designed for weight loss: both are about control, breathing and precision. Body weight depends on many factors (diet, rest, daily activity, health, medication) that no class controls on its own.
If weight is your reason for starting, your doctor or a dietitian-nutritionist can advise you. When choosing a format, think about what you’ll enjoy and stick with: that’s the key to pilates.
Combining both: a few options
You don’t have to commit to just one. Some common combinations:
- Start on the reformer and add mat at home. The machine gives you feedback early on; the mat lets you practise on non-studio days.
- Mat as your base, reformer now and then. You keep costs down and use the machine to work differently or clear up doubts.
- A few private sessions first, then group. Works for both, but makes particular sense for reformer, where there’s more technique to learn.
- Alternate by season. Some people focus on reformer in quieter periods and return to the mat when work or travel gets busy.
Practical tip: if you plan to combine, ask whether the class pack lets you mix formats and carry sessions over.
Questions to ask the studio before choosing
Keep them on your phone: front desk staff are usually happy to go into detail, and the answers help you picture your week. Many studio websites and front desks work in Spanish, so having your questions written down helps.
- What’s the maximum number of people in a reformer class? And in a mat class?
- Do you offer an intro class, starter private sessions or beginners-only groups?
- What training do the instructors have in each format?
- Can I try both formats before buying a class pack?
- Does the class pack cover reformer and mat, or are prices separate?
- How far ahead do I need to book and cancel for each type of class?
- What should I bring: grip socks, towel, my own mat?
- How do you adapt the class if I tell you about an injury or medical advice?
Your next step: read, prepare and compare
If you’re leaning towards the machine, read what reformer pilates is and how it works so you arrive knowing each part. If you’ve settled on a format, prepare with your first pilates class. Before paying anything, check how much pilates costs in Madrid to understand class packs, memberships and real cost per session. To compare studios on your own criteria, without rankings, see how to choose a pilates studio in Madrid. And if any term baffles you, the pilates glossary is there to help. Because, beyond machine or mat, choosing a format comes down to schedule, budget and consistency.
Frequently asked questions
Can I start straight on the reformer without ever having done a mat pilates class?
Yes, and many people do. What matters is not the order of formats but whether the studio has an onboarding process: an intro class, a few private sessions before group classes, or a beginners’ group. Ask how they do it before booking.
Is mat pilates easier than reformer?
Not necessarily. On the mat there are no springs to help or guide you, so many exercises rely on your control alone. The reformer has more mechanics to learn but gives you more feedback. They are different challenges, not steps on the same ladder.
Which one costs more?
Reformer usually costs more per session, because each person uses a machine and groups tend to be smaller. Actual prices vary a lot between studios and payment formats; we explain them on our prices page.
Does reformer help you lose more weight than mat pilates?
Neither format is designed for weight loss: both focus on control, breathing and precision. Weight depends on many factors no class controls on its own; for that goal, your doctor or a dietitian-nutritionist can advise you.
I have an injury or I’m pregnant. Which format suits me?
In your case, your doctor, physiotherapist or midwife is best placed to advise you. With their guidance, tell the instructor before your first class so they can adapt the session, on the reformer or the mat.